Interest in sustainable seafood has grown exponentially since the Vancouver Aquarium established its Ocean Wise Seafood Program in 2005. To date, the program includes more than 700 partners and has recently launched its own monitoring program for small-scale Canadian fisheries.
Author: Dalal Al-Abdulrazzak, PhD, Ocean Wise Seafood Specialist
Reviewer: Kurtis Hayne
Banner Photo Credit: Ocean Wise
In 2015, Ocean Wise began conducting assessments of small-scale Canadian fisheries to promote local sustainable seafood options. To date, Nunavut arctic char, Clayoquot Sound gooseneck barnacles, Chedabucto Bay trap-caught shrimp, and British Columbia giant pacific octopus and sea cucumber have all been assessed and recommended as Ocean Wise. Previously Ocean Wise relied strictly on assessments done by others, including Seafood Watch, but this practice limited seafood options from small-scale Canadian fisheries.
Ocean Wise aims to educate and empower consumers to make informed seafood choices and works with seafood industry business partners (i.e., fisheries, suppliers, retailers, restaurants, etc.) to meet their commitments to sourcing and selling sustainable seafood. In turn, partners identify these options on their menus or in their display cases with the Ocean Wise symbol. Ocean Wise’s classification system is based on two categories: Ocean Wise or Not recommended. Species are updated or reclassified every 3–5 years with the latest scientific information, and these changes are communicated to Ocean Wise partners.
Why is it important?
Overfishing is one of the biggest threats facing the global oceans today. The UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) estimates that 90 percent of the world’s fish stocks are fully fished or overfished. In 2014, Canada reported that 34 percent of major fish stocks were considered either critical or cautious, while many other commercially exploited stocks lack the scientific information needed to determine their health.
A rising awareness of overfishing in the late 1990s and early 2000s, saw an increase in sustainable seafood initiatives aimed at creating consumer awareness. The Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) was formed in London, UK in 1996 and is the largest global eco-certification body. MSC certified fisheries meet specific environmental and management standards as well as undergo independent audits for verification in order to carry the eco-label. A similar organization for aquaculture, the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC), was established in 2010.
In North America, many aquariums and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), such as Seafood Watch, took the lead in incorporating consumer-facing seafood recommendation programs into their outreach and education strategies. According to market research done by the Vancouver Aquarium, the most recognized seafood recommendation organization in Canada is the Ocean Wise Seafood Program, which was established in 2005.
Unlike the MSC, Ocean Wise is not focused on auditing and certifying fisheries, but rather works largely with consumers, restaurants, and retailers to source and consume products recommended as ‘sustainable’ based on the rigorous science-based assessments of Seafood Watch and MSC. The exception is the new work of Ocean Wise to assess small-scale Canadian fisheries based on Seafood Watch criteria. (For more information on rankings, certifications, and assessments see the Ocean Wise Standards webpage).
Sustainable seafood choices are available throughout the year in B.C. (Figure 1).
First Nations Connections
Within the sustainable seafood movement there is growing interest in ethical fisheries that give fair and equitable access to fisheries. The only gooseneck barnacle (Pollicipes polymerus) fishery in North America occurs off the west coast of Vancouver Island in Clayoquot Sound, near Tofino (Figure 2). This fishery is co-managed by the Canadian Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) and Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations. At present, the fishery is very small with only four groups of 2–3 individuals collecting barnacles from 48 designated harvest rocks. All fishers are members of the Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations and barnacles are gathered entirely by hand. In 2015, Ocean Wise conducted an assessment of this fishery and recommended it as sustainable option. Hand gathering is highly selective and this harvest method does not cause damage to the surrounding habitat and only causes minimal bycatch of attached mussels and juvenile barnacles.
What is the current status?
Since 2005 Ocean Wise has grown from just 16 local Vancouver restaurant partners to over 700 partners nationally, including suppliers, distributors, and retailers (Figure 3). As consumer demand for sustainable seafood grows, Ocean Wise has likewise expanded to include larger buyers (such as primary producers and suppliers) on the supply chain who are likely to have a bigger market impact. Partners receive up to date sustainability recommendations, access to training and marketing materials, and also benefit from Ocean Wise promotion.
Why do B.C. consumers eat fish?
Contributed by Karin Bodtker, MRM, Coastal Ocean Research Institute, an Ocean Wise initiative
Reviewed by Dr. Grant Murray, Associate Professor of Marine Policy, Duke University Marine Lab
A recent study (2017) into what matters most to British Columbians when they buy seafood at the supermarket found that taste, smell, and appearance ranked highest among 10 choices (Table 1).
|Factors||Percent of respondents who ranked this #1|
|Taste, smell, and appearance||34|
|Farmed versus wild seafood||15.6|
|Health benefits and nutritional value||12|
|Seafood is local||8|
|Sustainability of the species||4|
|Comfortable cooking or preparing seafood||3.4|
|Health risks such as allergies, mercury, etc.,||2|
|Cultural or religious reasons||0|
Terms like “local” and “sustainable” were not defined for participants in the study, so people made these choices based on whatever those terms meant to them.
Another interesting finding was that shoppers, overall, seem to be consuming seafood less frequently than they did as children (Figure 1). 82 percent of respondents ate seafood at least once a month as a child, while only 67 percent ate seafood with that frequency in the last year. At the other end of the spectrum, 15 percent of consumers never or almost never (i.e., not in the last year) eat seafood, but only six percent of that same group did not eat seafood as a child.
Interpretation and generalization of this work is limited for a few reasons:
- Seafood was referred to generically and not by type or species;
- Key terms (e.g., farmed, sustainable, local) were not defined, so each consumer applied their own personal understanding;
- Consumers were surveyed only in grocery stores/supermarkets; and
- Recall of childhood seafood consumption is not perfect.
What can you do?
Individual and Organization Actions:
- Next time you’re at the grocery store or a restaurant be sure to ask questions about what species it is, how it was caught or farmed, and where it is from.
- Look for the Ocean Wise symbol when buying seafood to ensure you are making the best choice for our oceans.
- Aim to eat lower on the trophic level – choose smaller forage fish such as sardines and mackerel, or farmed shellfish like clams and mussels, over larger fish such as salmon and halibut.
- Join a Community Supported Fisheries (CSF) such as Skipper Otto to connect with and purchase from local fishermen in your area.
Government Actions and Policy:
- Legislate improved seafood labelling in Canada (e.g., http://labelmyseafood.ca/).
- Allocate more resources to enforce fishery regulations and conduct regular scientific stock assessments of commercially caught species.
- Create more marine protected areas (MPAs) to allow fish stocks to recover.
- Eliminate harmful fishing subsidies of industrial fisheries that lead to overfishing and promote fuel-inefficient technology.